Honda Odyssey vs Toyota Sienna: Which Minivan Should You Buy?
Published November 12, 2026
The Honda Odyssey and Toyota Sienna are the two minivans most Brooklyn families end up choosing between. Both tow 3,500 pounds and start in the low $40,000s, but they are built around different ideas. Toyota sells the 2026 Sienna only as a hybrid and tunes it for fuel economy. Honda builds the 2026 Odyssey around the people inside: eight seats on every trim, Magic Slide second-row seats that move sideways and lift out, almost 55 cubic feet more maximum cargo space, a 280-hp V6 and leather from the first trim. In our scorecard the Odyssey wins 9 of 12 categories.
Odyssey or Sienna: Which Should You Buy?
- Our pick: the 2026 Honda Odyssey. It wins on seats, cargo, power, standard features, crash-test stars and top-trim price.
- More van from day one. The Odyssey EX-L starts at $42,795 with leather-trimmed seats, a power moonroof and Magic Slide seats. The Sienna LE is $1,375 less, with fabric seats and no moonroof.
- Luxury for thousands less. The Odyssey Elite costs $7,460 less than the Sienna Platinum.
- Where the Sienna fits: drivers who rank fuel economy (36 mpg against 22) or all-wheel drive above space, power and price.


How Do the 2026 Odyssey and Sienna Compare at a Glance?
| Spec | 2026 Honda Odyssey | 2026 Toyota Sienna | Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Seats | 8 on every trim | 8 on LE and XLE only; 7 on other grades | Odyssey |
| Second-row seats | Magic Slide: slide sideways and fore-aft, and lift out | Slide fore-aft; cannot be removed | Odyssey |
| Fuel economy and drivetrain | 22 mpg combined, FWD | 36 mpg (FWD), 35 (AWD); AWD on every grade | Sienna |
| Maximum cargo | 155.8 cu ft | 101.0 cu ft | Odyssey (+54.8 cu ft) |
| Power | 3.5L V6, 280 hp, 10-speed automatic | 2.5L hybrid, 245 hp | Odyssey (+35 hp) |
| Starting price and equipment | $42,795 (EX-L) with leather-trimmed seats and moonroof | $41,420 (LE) with fabric seats, no moonroof | Odyssey (more standard) |
| Towing and cargo behind 3rd row | 3,500 lb; 32.8 cu ft | 3,500 lb; 33.5 cu ft | Even |
| NHTSA frontal crash | 5 stars (5-star overall) | 4 stars (5-star overall) | Odyssey |
| Resale value | Strong Honda resale | KBB 2026 Best Resale Value, minivans | Sienna |
| Top-trim price | $51,695 (Elite) | $59,155 (Platinum) | Odyssey ($7,460 less) |
What Would Your Odyssey Cost Today?
Tell us which Odyssey trim you are considering, new or HondaTrue Certified, and how many seats your family needs. Our Odyssey team will reply with matching vans on the Plaza Honda lot, current offers and a written price.
Which Minivan Has More Flexible Seating?
The Odyssey. Every 2026 Odyssey seats eight, from the EX-L to the Elite, while the Sienna seats eight only as an LE or XLE; the XSE, Woodland, Limited and Platinum carry seven. The Odyssey's Magic Slide second-row seats move sideways as well as forward and back, so you can push one against the door for easy third-row access, slide the pair together to keep a toddler within reach, or lift them out. Second-row passengers also get an extra inch of legroom, 40.9 against 39.9 inches. The Sienna's second-row seats slide a long way fore and aft, but they stay in the van.


Which Has More Cargo Space?
The Odyssey, by a wide margin. With the rear rows folded or out, it holds 155.8 cubic feet against the Sienna's 101.0, room for a crib, two bikes or a dorm move in one trip. Behind the third row the two are effectively even, at 32.8 and 33.5 cubic feet, and both third rows fold into the floor.
Which Has Better Family Features?
The Odyssey gives you more from the base price. Every 2026 Odyssey has leather-trimmed seats, a power moonroof, a 9-inch touchscreen with wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, a wireless phone charger and the Honda Sensing suite. The Touring adds a 12.8-inch rear entertainment screen plus CabinWatch and CabinTalk, so you can see and talk to the back rows without turning around. The entry Sienna LE has fabric seats, no moonroof and an 8-inch screen; higher grades get a 12.3-inch display.


V6 or Hybrid: Which Is Better for Power, AWD and MPG?
The Odyssey's 3.5-liter V6 makes 280 hp, 35 more than the Sienna's hybrid, and pairs with a 10-speed automatic. That reserve shows when you merge onto the Belt Parkway with a full van. The Sienna's fuel economy is its strongest point: 36 mpg combined against 22. At 12,000 miles a year and $4.24 a gallon, the AAA New York metro average for regular on November 10, 2026, that is about $900 a year, or about $600 at 8,000 miles. The Odyssey Elite's $7,460 lower price than the Sienna Platinum covers more than eight years of that gap. The Sienna offers AWD on every grade; the front-drive Odyssey with winter tires handles plowed city streets well.
Which Minivan Is Safer?
Both earn a five-star overall rating from NHTSA, and the Odyssey scores five stars in the frontal crash test against four for the Sienna. Both include automatic emergency braking, lane keeping and adaptive cruise control as standard. Neither minivan earned a 2026 IIHS award; in the institute's updated moderate-overlap test, which checks rear-passenger protection, the Sienna scores better.
Which Is More Reliable, and Which Holds Its Value Better?
Both are dependable. Consumer Reports rates both the 2026 Odyssey and the 2026 Sienna average for predicted reliability, and the Odyssey ranked highest among minivans in J.D. Power's 2025 Initial Quality Study. On resale, the Sienna has the edge: Kelley Blue Book named it the 2026 Best Resale Value minivan.
How Do Odyssey and Sienna Trims and Prices Compare?
| Odyssey trim | Odyssey MSRP | What you get | Closest Sienna |
|---|---|---|---|
| EX-L | $42,795 | 8 seats, leather-trimmed seats, moonroof, Magic Slide, 9-in screen | LE FWD, $41,420 |
| Sport-L | $43,895 | Black exterior trim, sportier look | XSE AWD, $50,235 |
| Touring | $47,495 | Rear entertainment screen, CabinWatch, CabinTalk | XLE FWD, $46,120 |
| Elite | $51,695 | Ventilated front seats, heated steering wheel | Platinum AWD, $59,155 |
Shopping 2027 models? The 2027 Odyssey carries over the same V6, space and features; each trim is $400 higher, and the EX-L and Sport-L switch to synthetic leather.
What Do Owners Say About the Odyssey and Sienna?
On owner forums and Reddit threads, the same themes come up. Odyssey owners praise the Magic Slide seats, the smooth V6 when the van is loaded and the quiet, car-like ride. Sienna owners like the fuel savings and AWD, while the most common complaints are engine noise under hard acceleration and second-row seats that cannot come out. Families who haul gear or carpool with eight usually lean Odyssey.
Which Odysseys Are at Plaza Honda Now?
The Odysseys below are on our Brooklyn lot or arriving soon. Browse new Odyssey inventory, see every HondaTrue Certified Odyssey and used Odyssey, or search our full used inventory. Check current Honda specials, this month's Honda incentives and rebates and Honda financing before you visit, and keep your Odyssey on schedule with our service department. Call (855) 528-6785.
| TSRP | $44,790 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,792 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,173 |
| Price | $40,000 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $40,175 |
| TSRP | $44,790 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,792 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,173 |
| TSRP | $45,890 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,882 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $43,183 |
| TSRP | $45,155 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,883 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,447 |
| TSRP | $44,790 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,792 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,173 |
| TSRP | $45,155 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,883 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,447 |
| TSRP | $44,790 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,792 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,173 |
| TSRP | $45,890 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,882 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $43,183 |
| TSRP | $45,245 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,829 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,591 |
| TSRP | $44,790 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,792 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,173 |
| TSRP | $45,245 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,829 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,591 |
| TSRP | $45,155 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,883 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,447 |
| TSRP | $44,790 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,792 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,173 |
| TSRP | $45,385 |
| No Hassle discount | -$2,941 |
| Doc fee | $175 |
| Plaza Price | $42,619 |
Which Minivan Wins Our Scorecard?
The Odyssey wins 9 of 12 categories. Towing ties, and the Sienna takes fuel economy with AWD, plus resale.
| Category | Winner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Seating capacity | Odyssey | 8 seats on every trim; most Sienna grades seat 7 |
| Second-row flexibility | Odyssey | Magic Slide seats slide sideways and lift out |
| Fuel economy and AWD | Sienna | 36 vs 22 mpg combined; AWD on every grade |
| Maximum cargo | Odyssey | 155.8 vs 101.0 cu ft |
| Power | Odyssey | 280-hp V6 vs 245 hp |
| Standard features | Odyssey | Leather-trimmed seats and moonroof from the base EX-L |
| Towing | Tie | 3,500 lb each |
| Frontal crash rating | Odyssey | NHTSA 5 stars vs 4 |
| Initial quality | Odyssey | Highest-ranked minivan, J.D. Power 2025 IQS |
| Resale value | Sienna | KBB 2026 Best Resale Value minivan |
| Second-row legroom | Odyssey | 40.9 vs 39.9 in |
| Top-trim value | Odyssey | Elite costs $7,460 less than the Sienna Platinum |
Verdict: Which Minivan Should You Buy?
For most families, the 2026 Honda Odyssey. It carries more people and more cargo, makes more power, comes better equipped and costs far less at the top of the range. Choose the Sienna if fuel economy or AWD outranks everything else.
Eight seats, leather, moonroof
Magic Slide seats, the 280-hp V6 and more standard comfort than the Sienna LE, from $42,795.
Black-trim look
The EX-L's space and equipment with a sportier appearance for $1,100 more.
Rear screen
A 12.8-inch rear entertainment screen plus CabinWatch and CabinTalk to keep an eye on the back rows.
Top trim for less
Ventilated seats and a heated steering wheel for $51,695, $7,460 under the Sienna Platinum, with all eight seats.
Your Odyssey, brought home. Plaza Honda delivers your new Odyssey free within 25 miles, an area that covers the five boroughs and most of Nassau County, and our service team offers pickup and return across the NYC metro area.
Schedule Odyssey DeliveryHonda Odyssey vs Toyota Sienna: Frequently Asked Questions
Which is more reliable, the Odyssey or the Sienna?
Both are dependable. Consumer Reports rates the 2026 Odyssey and 2026 Sienna average for predicted reliability, and the Odyssey ranked highest among minivans in J.D. Power's 2025 Initial Quality Study.
Is the Odyssey bigger than the Sienna?
Inside, yes. The Odyssey holds 155.8 cubic feet of maximum cargo against the Sienna's 101.0, seats eight on every trim and gives second-row passengers 40.9 inches of legroom against 39.9. Behind the third row the two are nearly even.
Which hybrid gets better MPG, the Odyssey or the Sienna?
Only the Sienna is a hybrid. It is rated 36 mpg combined with FWD and 35 with AWD. The Odyssey uses a 280-hp V6 rated 22 mpg combined, trading fuel economy for 35 more horsepower.
Which gets better gas mileage?
The Sienna, at 36 mpg combined against the Odyssey's 22. At 12,000 miles a year and $4.24 a gallon, the difference is about $900 a year. The Odyssey Elite costs $7,460 less than the Sienna Platinum, which covers more than eight years of that difference.
Which tows more, the Odyssey or the Sienna?
Neither. Both the 2026 Odyssey and the 2026 Sienna tow up to 3,500 pounds, enough for a small camper or a pair of jet skis.
How much does a 2026 Honda Odyssey cost?
The 2026 Odyssey starts at $42,795 for the EX-L and tops out at $51,695 for the Elite, before destination. The Sport-L is $43,895 and the Touring $47,495.
Which Plaza Auto Mall Store Can Help You Next?
Plaza Honda is part of Plaza Auto Mall, family-owned on Nostrand Avenue in Brooklyn since 1975. Pick a store to browse what is on its lot today.
*MSRP excludes destination, tax, title and registration. Honda and Toyota set destination charges that can vary by region; for buyers in Brooklyn, New York, Honda charges $1,495 for the 2026 Odyssey and Toyota charges $1,495 for the 2026 Sienna. Sources: American Honda, 2026 Odyssey pricing and specifications; Toyota Motor North America, 2026 Sienna pricing and specifications; EPA, fueleconomy.gov; NHTSA 5-Star Safety Ratings; IIHS; Consumer Reports predicted reliability; J.D. Power 2025 U.S. Initial Quality Study; Kelley Blue Book 2026 Best Resale Value Awards; AAA, New York metro average for regular gasoline (November 10, 2026). EPA ratings are estimates for comparison, and your mileage will vary. Current as of November 12, 2026; ask Plaza Honda to confirm prices and availability.





